I don’t like the term “retired,” it should really be split into two: trashed and on hold.

I personally group my library by my desire to play:

• probably never - essentially trash
• replay - games I enjoyed and intend to revisit
• done - games I enjoyed and have no intent to revisit

So for me, “retired” could be any of those three. I don’t always “finish” games (credits roll, 100% complete, etc), so the label doesn’t really say much about the quality of the game or whether people enjoyed it, just that they decided to set it aside for whatever reason.

I wonder how Starfield didn’t make it to that list. Maybe it’s #11?

Lol, Forza at #3 two months after release. It hurts. They truly botched the release.

Atomic Heart was the only game I played on this list this year. I did finish it though, no thanks to the absurd QTE in the final boss battle