Not all humans inherently deserve rights just because they are human. Think of people like Hiter, Jeffrey Dahmer, and the dozens of other evil people. No one would reasonably think they deserve sympathy, because of what they chose to do.

If your evil enough to commit such a heinous act as child rape, I don’t see any legitimate reason why that person should deserve any sort of sympathy.

Subconsciously everyone agrees on this to some extent. Look at prisons, (depending on the crime) they remove your right to vote, own a gun, even walk outside, and have certain jobs.

The reason I believed my take is controversial is because of how I think those pedos would lose their rights. I believe people as evil as them aren’t people at all. They are simply containers of flesh with a human face, and should be seen as such. I have no issue with the idea they should be used as slaves and test subjects. Arguably this would actually benefit humanity (especially in terms of medicine) because now instead of risking the lives of innocent people like doctors or everyday Joe’s, we could use them to see if the experimental drug has any side effects. Honestly, what are they going to do? Revoke consent? I wonder of the child they raped got that same privilege…

I’m sure this goes without saying but the person would have to be caught red-handed with undeniable proof to be subjected to this

  • BezzelBob@lemmy.worldOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    12
    ·
    1 month ago

    But it also seems to be a lot of American’s and literal Nazi ideals.

    It’s surprising how fast people jump to Nazis when they can’t find anything else to argue. Did yk the Nazis breathed air, that must make breathing evil. The nazis had jobs and worked in government, that must mean jobs are evil.

    Nazis aren’t evil because of what they did, but who and why they did it to. Hitler targeted innocent people because he was a racist. Child rapists are not innocent people.

    I honestly can’t wrap my brain around how idiotic and 1 dimensional these arguments are. Fr the only legitimate argument any of you have made is one guy said that the people in power would frame non rapists in order to enslave them. Other than that one guy, everything that everyone has said has been along these same lines “well, your doing bad so that makes you bad” under that logic all prison systems, wars against legitimate terrorists, or any kind of punishment would be banned. Without repercussion people would be walking around doing whatever they wanted.

    • Tangentism@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      1 month ago

      Nazis aren’t evil because of what they did, but who and why they did it to.

      I bet that sounded better in your head

    • Maeve@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      1 month ago

      SMH. These arguments aren’t the ones that are one dimensional. I’m not arguing anything because nothing but that your own arse could be targeted for punishment, rightly or wrongly, has given you pause. That’s sick. It’s dangerous to society. Please seek behavioral therapy. Your thinking screams that you find pleasure in making others suffer and are seeking to justify that when it’s not justifiable. I understand you probably can’t help thinking that way. You can seek a qualified therapist to evaluate whether you can or can’t, and to keep those impulses under control, if you can’t. Otherwise, to keep yourself from forced labor or torture or a gruesome death.

      • BezzelBob@lemmy.worldOP
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        5
        ·
        1 month ago

        These arguments aren’t the ones that are one dimensional

        Really? Okay let’s break down your argument then. “it’s a nazi way of thinking” which would make me Hitler, correct? Which would make the child rapists the jews. You see how dumb that sounds? Making the comparison from monsters like rapist to innocent people… it makes no sense.

        That’s sick. It’s dangerous to society

        Punishing child rapists is dangerous to society? How exactly? Because I could argue letting them walk free is worse for obvious reasons.

        You need therapy

        It’s easy to throw out words with nothing to back you up. I could just as easily say your trying to defend rapists and not back up my statement with anything, just as you are.

        So please explain exactly how I’m crazy and how it’s dangerous to society to rid the world of rapists. Because as of now you’ve said nothing.