Thank you !lifehacks@sh.itjust.works community!

tldr: baking/steaming garlic in the peel is the clear winner for volume clove peeling.

Crushing is the winner for a couple cloves in a stir-fry, root end cut is obviously better for garlic chips.

The last garlic peeling post had so many good suggestions that I decided to trial each of them at least a few times with fresh/older bulbs of different shapes and sizes.

One method worked in any situation.

For peeling as many cloves as you want, each technique had some major cons except for the final, winning method put forward by @TheAlbatross@lemmy.blahaj.zone !

The results were:

Smashing -

pros: easy, classic technique. usually works.

cons: peel can get stuck inside a smash, you still have to pull off the peel, occasionally the peel is still stuck to the skin, cloves are damaged.

Slicing off root end and peeling -

pros: easy, faster

cons: still have to manually peel it, much faster but not fast.

Garlic roller -

pros: I cannot find one. Sometimes works?

cons: can only roll a couple of cloves at a time, much more effort than other methods, have to either cut off the ends first or later, so you’re doing all the work without any benefit. These are a no for me, dawg.

Shaking -

pros: fun to do, does work for more than half the cloves of large batches using two aluminum popcorn bowls for a minute of shaking.

cons: a LOT of effort, bruises the cloves before cooking, very messy, juice everywhere, inevitably doesn’t peel every clove, so you have to spend time hand peeling the leftovers, even with prep work of slicing off top and root end.

WINNER is root end cut and steaming or roasting in peel as suggested by @TheAlbatross@lemmy.blahaj.zone:

pros: least effort, safest, cooking is already done, fastest and simplest clove peeling, no bruising beforehand, least messy

Method:

Cut off root end.

Steam(~10 minutes) or bake(400 degrees ~30 min) as much garlic as you want.

Let garlic sit for a few minutes to cool down.

Pinch the top end of each peel and the clove will pop out easily, discard peel.

Mash the garlic together and season however you like for a garlic dip.