A couple of months ago I wrote a single comment under a post about a hateful rage upon israel in c/news, literally I wrote “What could Hamas do to end the violence?”

Nothing else.

And I got immediately banned.

The moderators refuse to answer my messages.

Not even that, they even banned a buddy who spoke up in my defence per message - not per c/news but really just a personal message to be sure.

In 15 years of Reddit my posts got deleted a lot - but NEVER my comments and I got NEVER banned for anything.

If this is what Lemmy wants to be, then be it but without me.

Do you think this is what Lemmy needs to be?

  • JonsJava@lemmy.worldEnglish
    4·
    18 days ago

    It’s not that simple though; Israel wants to eliminate Hamas (and they have plenty of reason for that – if Mexico attacked the US like Hamas attacked Israel, there would simply put no longer be a Mexico). It would be tone deaf to Israel to say “leave Gaza” without that mission accomplished. They claim they don’t even want the area, they just want Hamas gone. Furthermore, Hamas is fighting with guerilla tactics. They’re intentionally trying to provoke war crimes. Israel doesn’t have to be so dang willing to fall for the trap. However, Hamas is making it exceptionally hard to fight a clean war from what I’ve read. Citizens in the Gaza strip are not just being abused by the IDF but by Hamas. I wouldn’t be surprised if Biden has his own Intel to back that all up. If it were as obvious as people want it to be, I’m pretty sure we would’ve stopped sending aid by now.

    This was the comment. Emphasis added.

    The reason a mod called it bad faith: Israelis were actively settling the land after the IDF cleared it out.

    • Dark Arc@social.packetloss.ggEnglish
      2·
      18 days ago

      Thanks for finding it; I couldn’t on my mobile app.

      Also if that’s the reason it was “bad faith”, I think a far more appropriate action is to just say “they’re actively settling the land they claim they don’t want anyways” ideally with a citation as a comment.

      That sentence was a fraction of what I’d said anyways. To remove the whole comment due to an objection to one sentence is ridiculous.

      • JonsJava@lemmy.worldEnglish
        2·
        18 days ago

        Looking back, that was a bad day, with tons of reports coming in, and I believe the mod team was just working the reports as fast as they could.

        • Dark Arc@social.packetloss.ggEnglish
          2·
          17 days ago

          We’re all only human and it’s a hot button issue that’s divisive even within the left leaning US political spectrum. Still, I suspect you can appreciate how frustrating it is from my perspective and why it has sat with me rather unfondly.

          The Lemmy attitude has been staunchly anti-Israel (and at times frighteningly pro-Hamas) across the platform and having moderators remove a “mild mannered” comment, not in support of Israel, but in defense of situational nuance… It just further reinforces that narrative.

          As I recall that day, several people I was engaging with were being much more uncivil and fervent than I was; Lemmy’s moderation weirdness likely doesn’t help as I’m not sure cross-instance reports really do much.

          • JonsJava@lemmy.worldEnglish
            2·
            17 days ago

            As a mod, what I can say is this:

            If something of yours is removed, or you receive a ban, send us a message. We can work through it. Also, if you see something, report it.

            We’re volunteers, and don’t police every comment or post, as we have full-time jobs. We tend to look at the reports, try to gather some context if time allows, then take action or not, based on the community rules.

            Thanks for your feedback. I really appreciate it!