Not that I expect a lot of consistency from imperialists, but essentially the same lines of argument can be used regarding the Russian Federation.
An advisory opinion would effectively settle Israel’s “bilateral dispute” without the state’s consent.
Ditto for .ru and .ua.
The court is not equipped to examine a “broad range of complex factual issues concerning the entire history of the parties’ dispute”.
Same thing, especially if we get back to the formation of the Soviet Union, independence referenda, and so on.
An advisory opinion would conflict with existing agreements between the parties and negotiation frameworks endorsed by the UN.
This would be Minsk I and II.
The request is not appropriate as it asks the court to “assume unlawful conduct on the part of Israel”.
Ditto.
This is the best summary I could come up with:
The UK statement has been met with dismay by Palestinian diplomats, as well as international humanitarian law experts, who say it ignores not just the fact that Israel’s occupation is entrenched, but that the situation is rapidly deteriorating.
A UN general assembly resolution in December requested the advisory opinion from the ICJ on the “legal consequences arising from the policies and practices of Israel in the occupied Palestinian territory”.
Since then, Israeli settlement and infrastructure building in the West Bank and East Jerusalem has accelerated, and settler violence against Palestinian communities is at its highest level since records began in 2005.
Of particular relevance to the ICJ referral is the transfer of several aspects of the administration of the West Bank from military control to a pro-settlements civilian minister – a move rights groups point out constitutes de jure annexation.
It also does not reference relevant UN findings since 2016 that Israel has repeatedly failed to fulfil its obligation to uphold the rights of the Palestinian people and violated international humanitarian law.
An international criminal court (ICC) investigation into alleged war crimes committed by both Israeli army personnel and Palestinian armed groups officially opened in 2021, but is progressing slowly.
The original article contains 994 words, the summary contains 200 words. Saved 80%. I’m a bot and I’m open source!
