• 63 Posts
  • 1.08K Comments
Joined 1 年前
cake
Cake day: 2024年10月12日

help-circle










  • I met German guy a year or two ago who worked as a spy for West Germany in the 1980s. He freely admitted that the GDR put up the wall for good reasons. I asked him which side of the wall he liked better. He had to think for a minute and said ‘West. They have a more exciting nightlife… but the East was quieter and the people there were more kind’



  • I agree with your outline here. Although I think there are deeper roots to the corruption problem that go back to lack of ideological coherence between regions, ethnic groups and factions during the war. Obviously, Uncle Ho was very good at getting ideologically disparate people to unite against colonialism, but afterwards getting everyone to understand and believe in socialist reconstruction has been a bigger challenge. Its a small country, but attitudes, dialects and world views can vary to the extreme depending on where you are. The corruption we have to deal with here, comes from people who only believe in money and family. It is a great shame to see so many wear the uniform and the symbols, but not care at all about what they are supposed to represent.



  • I’d prefer not to be too specific, but lets say south-central. I travel to TPHCM/Bien Hoa somewhat frequently and I’ve been as far north as Ha Noi and Lao Cai. There is definitely a reactionary bias here. What region do you live in?

    I’ve had to explain what a color revolution is, and how they operate, to full-grown adults here. I’d love to be more optimistic too.

    I know being critical of VN is personally dangerous and also likely to tilt the mods here. Anyone here who doesn’t think a Viet ML, living in Viet Nam, doesn’t know how it is, I invite them to come learn the language and live here for a year and see for themselves.






  • Not in my experience.

    I live in a south-central area of the country where it’s still fairly rural. Maybe it’s a little better up north, I don’t go to Hanoi very often. Down here, no one even knows what communism or socialism are, nor are they inclined to discuss it. Especially not openly. Saying anything political can get you arrested, so people avoid the topic entirely.

    The entry point to anything ostensibly political is generally by joining the police and working you way up. The police and government officials are basically just motivated by taking bribes and making connections.

    Don’t let our flags, decorations and art fool you, most people here think that shit is annoying. People will roll their eyes if you speak positively of it (or mention it all, really). Uncle Ho is a mainly figure of nationalism and there’s little understanding of what he believed in beyond studying his poetry (though everyone will tell you they are an “expert” about Uncle Ho). The symbols of communism are usually associated with nationalism, so positive views toward communism tend to represent an internalized sense of masculine strength.

    I was recently talking to a couple kids who completed primary last year and was trying to start a business together. Neither of them knew who Marx, Lenin or Mao where. Weird since Lenin (LêNin) appears all over the place in school books. I never went to the primary schools here, so I don’t know what’s going on there.

    The bookstores here don’t sell anything related to Marxist theory, economics or history at all. BUT they DO sell hagiographies of Richard Nixon, Friedman, Trump, Trump Jr., Henry Kissinger, Karl Rove, Betsy DeVos, Netanyahu, Modi, Ronald Reagan, Papi Bush, Dick Cheney, John Bolton, etc… I get pretty mad about it sometimes. Some of the kids here think it’s really fucked up too, so maybe there’s some hope. I have to order most of my books in English and from outside the country.


  • The actual expats have their own little quarter in TPHCM and don’t bother anybody for the most part.

    It’s the US social media, NGOs and CIA-linked schools that are doing the most damage. Going to these western schools is a sign of prestige and wealth, and you can probably guess what they teach and you’d be right.

    There’s something of a scandal at one of these schools a few years ago that the students were being shown hollywood movies about the Viet Nam war, and being taught to be extremely sympathetic to the invading genicodal nazis – to the extent that Vietnamese students were literally crying about how sad it was that Amerikkkans were “forced” to kill Vietnamese.