You can find much more of my content at my Mastodon account: @tcely@fosstodon.org

  • 3 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 6th, 2023

help-circle







  • Why would my way of counting the approval ratio rather than approval-only be of any disadvantage?

    That’s just how voting systems work. Even seemingly insignificant changes to the algorithm can have outsized impacts on how well it performs.

    Plurality versus Approval is a specific example of this. Just changing “choose one” to “choose as many as you approve of” significantly impacts the amount of data that’s captured and often the outcome because of the effects on voters’ behaviors.

    I liked the suggestion of more information. When we have it all figured out those details should be included as you suggested.



  • I like some of those suggestions. However, I don’t think down voting or abstaining should be supported. You either support an option by up voting or you take no action.

    Approval voting systems have well studied behaviors and we should not deviate from that without a compelling reason.

    Every approval / upvote is a distinct user endorsement for an option. The option with the most users endorsing it should be selected when that number exceeds 51% of the active users set we decide on.