cross-posted from: https://lemy.lol/post/21886458
While Judaism is excluded despite never having any conflict with them.
Why the same excuse which is used to exclude muslims and Jews is not used to exclude Christians?
Are they afraid of western retribution? What is the logic behind keeping Christianity but excluding Judaism?
There are plenty of Christian countries for Christians to go to just like muslims. So, why include Christians?
So first of all I don’t know what is muhammadians.
Secondly you consider them hostile based on the past like
Jalia wala bagh was a very friendly event.
And you are talking about the future but connect present muhammadians with the actions of monarchies in the mediaeval period who do not take actions based on the wishes of the subject irrespective of their religion. If they favour some religion it’s their fault not the fault of the community they are favouring. If they treat everyone equally it’s their goodwill.
Most muhammadians in India that are alive today are converts. They didn’t come from anywhere. Their descendants are genetically linked to Indian land. They are not responsible for what muhammadian Kings did, Good or bad.
Thirdly India was never a country until British colonised it and made it one. Before that it was 1000s of kingdoms and kings usually takeover each other’s empire. Irrespective of religion it’s not considered an invasion.
India never had a unique identity even to this day. Obviously British tried their best. But that’s the beauty of India. We will never be a monolith.